First Presbyterian Church of Barberton held its first Sunday worship in this location on March 1, 1931. The members of three congregations shaped the founding of the present church: Reformed Church of Barberton, Presbyterian Church of Barberton, and the Doylestown Presbyterian Church.

A tremendously thorough resource for a detailed history of the congregation is available at the church: “History – First United Presbyterian Church of Barberton, 1892-1967.”